By all accounts, she was a fairly easy baby. Our life did not change much when she was born. She went with us everywhere and was a very content, friendly baby. If I was not well-informed of the Bible’s teaching on Original Sin, I would not have acquired that knowledge through the first twelve months of her behavior. Around twelve months old, however, Maddie discovered a thirst for climbing the stairs. And since she had not expressed any interest in the stairs until then, we did not have a gate to keep her from this temptation.
And tempted, she was.
One day, Maddie crawled resolutely toward the stairs. I clearly remember telling her, “No, no. Maddie.” And, as if it were this morning, I remember her quizzical expression and smile. Then she turned to the stairs and gave them a longing glance. Then, she turned back to me. “No, no. Maddie, no stairs. Dangerous.” My facial expression punctuated my words and my tone. Maddie’s eyes sparkled. A Cheshire cat-like grin from my little princess’ face turned from my firm gaze. She began crawling in high gear, motoring quickly to put her hands on the stairs. She pulled herself up. Standing proudly and ready to take her next step up the stairs, she looked at me hoping for approval. My face remained firm. I stood up. Maddie giggled; she began climbing the next stair. Clearly, she felt we were playing a game. Before she was able to climb stair number two, I held her arm, caught her attention and said, “No, Maddie.” Then, I gave Maddie a firm pat just below the diaper line; she cried, I consoled her, and warned her again, and then turned her attention to some other play thing.
Later that day, we bought a gate for the stairs. Additionally, I began reading at a furious pace what the Bible says about parenting, discipline, and spanking. I really didn’t want to spank my child – especially at such a young age, but as a very attentive dad, I knew Maddie had turned a corner toward independence. Independence without wisdom and preparation leads to disaster – like sending your child off to college having never taught him anything about personal banking (Wisdom I learned the hard way when I was 18: the balance issued by the ATM machine is not really your balance! ha.). So, after blazing through book after book on parenting and discipline, I began to develop a more intentional approach toward spanking. I’ll report more on this in a future Part 2 of this article. This article has a different purpose.
But back to our current episode: In “Maddie Meets the Stairs”, I assertively corrected her via corporal punishment, a spank, as a means to teach my child that she had crossed a line. She chose a path of disobedience AND danger; therefore, she needed a consequence, and she needed my help so that she wouldn’t be tempted to continue to test this boundary (Thus, we bought the gate.). Consider that God says, “Fathers, do not exasperate your children, but build them up in the nurture and admonition of the Lord” (Ephesians 6:4). I would have exasperated Maddie had I allowed her foolish to become habit, withheld instruction in the consequences for disobedience, and left her to her folly (not bought a gate). She was a little child after all, and as much I wanted to treat this as an obedience issue, I knew that she was also a little child prone to childishness. Childishness is normal, but childishness can be sin. Thus, I wanted to recognize the sin and give an appropriate consequence (a spank); however, I would have been foolish not to have purchased a gate. Had I not purchased the gate, I might have neglected another Proverb: “As a dog returns to his vomit, so a fool repeats his folly” (Proverbs 26:11). As much as my stomach turns at the mention of vomit, I am nauseous at the thought of allowing babies to craw willy-nilly up my stairs.
Noted Christian psychologist, Dr. James Dobson (founder of Focus on the Family), has stated that the sinful disobedience line is normally not crossed willfully by a child until a child is 18 to 24 months old. Until that time, Dobson asserts, children are just exploring and discovering their environment. Not that I totally disagree with Dobson, but I do view his assertion from a different vantage point. His assessment was in terms of the “average” toddler. Thus, some children need corrective discipline before 18 months and others simply need “re-direction” or little corrective discipline throughout their preschool years. Consequently, I have seen far too few parents who have taken this statement from Dobson as “Don’t discipline/spank your children until they are 2.” Additionally, because of similar assertions by many secular experts on child behavior, many Christian parents have deceived themselves into thinking their child is innocently making destructive choices in their toddler years. Nothing is further from the truth. No human is born in innocence (Romans 5:12-21). Often, parents allow their children to persist in being disrespectful to them or passively dismiss the willful child who persistently says, “NO!” to their parents wise commands.
Please hear me. I’m not being to quick judge. I know personally the angst of wondering, “What am I going to do about this? Will this child quit it?! I’m embarrassed!” Often, you will have to excuse yourself from adult conversation to address a behavior issue. And, you should do this with the full confidence that the adult community supports your actions. My wife and I had one very clear principle if one of our children persisted in these rebellious comments or a difficult attitude out in public: Get to a private place quickly with the child (the nearest bathroom or our car). I would get down on their level, look in their eyes, and firmly correct them, and if need be give them a spank to affirm the principle. While public rebuke can and is often done in a very godly way, public rebuke can work against you and shame a child. Shame causes further rebellion and anger. What would you desire? Should your boss illuminate your poor performance in front of an entire staff meeting? Wouldn’t you rather he talk to you personally?
My second, Jake, provides another illustration which helps understand the bigger picture on this issue of corrective discipline with toddlers.
Recently, Jake was reading the book of Proverbs in my copy of the Bible, and he came across Proverbs 10:1: “A wise son makes a glad father, but a foolish son is the grief of his mother.” In the margin next to this verse, he read my handwriting which said, “Jake….Blinds”. So, Jake inquired about my note. Thus, I shared with him the wondrous tale about Jake and the Mini-blinds.
Jake and the Mini-blinds
Once upon a time, in a family room in Memphis, Tennessee, a dad named Ted sat reading, enjoying his morning coffee, and watching his children play on the floor. While his daughter flit about her Playschool kitchen industriously making her own plastic breakfast, Ted noticed the world’s second fastest crawling toddler, Jake, casting a longing gaze at the shining mini-blinds. Perhaps 14 month old Jake had never noticed them before; perhaps Jake had realized he could now pull himself up high enough to touch those flat pieces of shimmering plastic wood. Jake began crawling giddily toward the window.
Having been broken in by his eldest child, Ted knew exactly what was going on in Jake’s curious mind. “Jake,” said Ted with an I-wasn’t-born-yesterday, clear diction. Mid-crawl, Jake paused, shifted his leg under his upper torso as if he was preparing to break dance, plopped his rear down on the floor (How do babies do that?), and looked at Ted wondering if he had done something to displease his dad. Ted walked over to the blinds. He held them and said firmly with a somewhat cross expression, “No, Jake. Danger. No, no.” Going back to his seat with post-traumatic stress disorder from his days training Maddie not to play with doors, steps, mini-blinds and those boingy door stoppers, Ted sat wondering what Jake would do next. Would this be Jake’s first spanking?
Jake looked at Ted. Jake looked at the window. Jake looked back at Ted. Jake crawled over to the play kitchen to see what big sister was cooking. Ted sat and mused, “What a wise son. Phew.”
Proverb: “A wise son makes a glad father.”
Jake then knew why I scrawled in the margin of my Bible: “Jake…Blinds.”
Both stories above are necessary in this article to illustrate several truths about even the youngest of children:
- Children are born in sin and tempted by sin and folly, and this sin and folly comes both from within them (Original Sin) and from without (peers, the environment, disobedient parents, the Devil, etc.). The Bible summarizes this: “Foolishness is bound up in the heart of a child…” (Prov. 22:15a). I witnessed this truth years ago in a very humorous situation. I attended a baby baptism of some Roman Catholic friend’s child. The priest anointed the child with oil and prayed over the baby. The priest then said, “This rite was done to remove Original Sin from this child.” The sweet newborn’s mother who while watching the priest was also observing the precocious conduct of one of her two older children (the one who was playfully poking the eyes of a statue of Mary), replied winsomely to the priest’s comment, “Would you mind doing this other one again?” We all laughed. Even a faithful Roman Catholic parent sees that a child continues to struggle against Original Sin even after they are baptized.
- Each child is a unique person with an individual personality, struggles, and gifts.
- Children are curious about their surroundings: the good and bad, and the dangerous and the safe.
- Children’s parents must be consistent to help them discern the good and the bad, the dangerous and the safe.
- Children in the same family respond differently to the same consistent parent and guidelines. I’ve trained four very unique children to stay in their bed at night unless they have an emergency. Training my 1st and 3rd children required lots of attention; my 2nd and 4th children were fairly easy.
- Children are not “blank slates” as educators are often taught; children come with natural bents. God knows I can’t play the guitar, but my second and third children seem naturally gifted at guitar. I as a parent have the job of discerning these bents and directing/shaping/encouraging the child to make the most of these gifts of God.
- Children need (indeed, they often crave!) boundaries, correction, and training. The second half of the Proverb stated above declares, “Foolishness is bound up in the heart of the child; the rod of reproof will drive it far from him” (Prov. 22:15). On more than one occasion, a child at school has told me, “I was bad; I need a spanking.” This does not mean they want or like spankings! Physical correction is often necessary in training a child.
- The Bible informs Christian parents (and all parents really) on the content, the goal, and the methods of instructing children. Rejecting, mis-applying, and conversely applying correctly these methods reap consequences (“We reap what we sow.” ~ Galatians 6:7).
Another article will be forthcoming on the method and process involved in Christian corporal punishment, but for now, this content above is meant to establish the reality we face as parents in training our children’s behavior and character. My conclusions have been drawn from the scriptures as well as these resources below which have been life changing reads for me as a parent. I think in each of the below you will find that the goal of the author (and the goal of the scriptures) is not to produce mechanical parenting. The goal is to facilitate redemptive, restorative, and godly parenting. Indeed, we struggle as much as our children do in cultivating wisdom and holiness.
- Shepherding a Child’s Heart by Ted Tripp
- Withhold Not Correction by Bruce Ray
- Standing on the Promises by Douglas Wilson
- Teach Them Diligently by Lou Priolo
- The Bible: especially the book of Solomon’s Proverbs